ASWAD Research Centrum
Building a Better World through Research, Innovation, and Sustainability

Here are essential guidelines for reviewers reviewing articles for a journal:

Familiarize yourself with the journal’s scope and the specific guidelines for reviewers.

Assess the manuscript for originality, relevance, and significance to the field.

Evaluate the clarity and coherence of the writing, including the structure and flow of the argument.

Check the methodology for appropriateness and rigor, ensuring that it is well-described and reproducible.

Consider the validity of the results and whether they are supported by the data presented.

Review the discussion for depth and relevance, ensuring that conclusions are justified by the findings.

Assess the completeness of the literature review and the appropriateness of citations.

Provide constructive feedback, highlighting both strengths and areas for improvement.

Be specific in your comments to help the authors understand your perspective.

Maintain a professional tone and avoid personal biases in your evaluation.

Respect confidentiality; do not disclose the manuscript’s content or discuss it with others.

Submit your review within the specified timeframe to facilitate timely publication.

If you identify a conflict of interest, disclose it to the editor and consider recusing yourself from the review.

Be open to the possibility that your assessment may differ from other reviewers; provide a rationale for your opinions.

Remember that your feedback plays a crucial role in enhancing the quality of published research.